864-502-8280 | Starting Nov. 8: Worship Sundays @ 3 p.m. through March
By Rev Danielle Elliott
The last thing God says in the book of Jonah is a question, and it ends with four words that most of us have read many times without really stopping on them. “And also many animals.” God has just asked Jonah whether God should not care about a great city of more than a hundred and twenty thousand people who cannot tell their right hand from their left, and then God adds the cattle.
It would be easy to read that as a way of finishing the sentence, but I don’t think the writer meant it that way. The book ends by telling us how far God’s concern reaches, beyond the people we like and the people we fear, all the way to the livestock. The animals were part of the story earlier than that, too.
In chapter 3, when the king of Nineveh hears Jonah’s warning, he gets down off his throne, takes off his robe, puts on sackcloth, and sits in ashes. Then he sends out a decree that no person and no animal, no herd and no flock, is to eat or drink anything, and that everyone and everything is to be covered in sackcloth and cry out to God. Imagine that picture for a minute. Cattle and sheep in mourning clothes, hungry and thirsty and confused, standing in the streets of the most feared city on earth.
Jonah never says a word about the animals. He is so busy being angry at the people that he cannot see anything else, and yet God does. When God finally gets the last word, God speaks up for the ones who cannot speak for themselves.
The one piece of creation Jonah did care about was the plant. God grew it over his head and he was delighted, because it gave him shade, and when it died he wanted to die right along with it. I think a lot of us love creation in just that way. We love it while it shades us, and we lose interest when it stops being useful or when caring about it becomes inconvenient.
To understand why God cares about the animals, I think we have to go back to the beginning. In the first chapter of Genesis, God makes the sky and the sea and the land and everything that fills them, and over and over God looks at what has been made and calls it good. All of that happens before a single human being appears. The fish and the birds and the creatures of the field are good to God for their own sake, not because we find them useful. Only after that does God make humans, and then God looks at the whole of it and calls it very good.
That brings us to a verse that has been misused for a long time. God makes humans in the divine image and gives them dominion over every living thing, and plenty of people have heard permission in that word. But think about what an image meant in the ancient world. Kings often set up statues of themselves in the far corners of their territory so that people who never laid eyes on the king would know whose land they were standing on and how that king ruled. To be made in God’s image is to be placed in creation to show the rest of it what God is like, and the book of Jonah has already shown us what God is like. God is the one who holds back the fire. So dominion in the image of that God has to mean ruling the way God rules, with care and with mercy. The second chapter of Genesis puts it in plainer terms. God places the first human in a garden to tend it and keep it, which is a gardener’s work, and a gardener is someone who answers for what grows and what withers.
So much of creation is of no use to us at all. We live at the foot of the Blue Ridge Mountains, and the hills just up the road are home to more kinds of salamanders than anywhere else on earth, and most of us will go our whole lives without seeing one. They don’t feed us or shade us or earn anybody a dollar, yet God made them and delights in them. If the only creation we care about is the part that is useful to us, we have missed what Genesis is telling us.
Genesis says the earth had filled with violence, and God saw it and grieved, and the waters came. Only Noah and his family survived, and with them the animals. When the water went down and Noah made an offering, the Bible does something surprising. God speaks in his own heart and says, I will never again curse the ground because of humankind, even though the inclination of the human heart is evil from youth, and I will never again destroy every living creature as I have done.
What strikes me about that promise is that God does not make it because people have gotten better. God makes it even though they haven’t. God looks at the whole record of human violence and decides that destruction is not going to be the answer, and God chooses mercy knowing exactly who we are.
Then God makes the first covenant in the Bible, and it includes more than we usually remember. It is with Noah and his descendants, and it is also, God says again and again, with every living creature, the birds and the livestock and every animal of the earth. The sign of the covenant is the rainbow, and many scholars point out that the bow in the clouds is a warrior’s bow, hung up like a weapon on a wall. God says that when the bow appears, God will look at it and remember.
Now picture Jonah on his hill. He is waiting for fire from heaven, which means he is waiting for another flood, and he is furious that God will not send it. But God made a promise about that at the rainbow, and the promise included the cattle. When God says at the end of the book, and also many animals, I don’t believe that is an afterthought. I believe God is keeping a promise made to every living creature after the waters went down.
Paul writes that the whole creation has been groaning together like a woman in labor, and that it waits with eager longing for the children of God to be revealed, because creation itself will be set free from its bondage to decay.
The part that is easy to overlook is who creation is waiting for. It is waiting for the children of God. I read that to mean that the rest of creation is watching us, and that its hope is tied up with whether people will live as God’s children. If that is true, then the animals in Nineveh, hungry in their sackcloth, were waiting on the choices of their people, and so is every river and forest and species today. Paul also makes clear that we are not the only ones in pain. Creation groans, he says, and we groan too, waiting for our own redemption. We belong to the earth, and what happens to it happens to us. The hope God has for us is a hope God has for it.
More than fifty years ago, this country decided to do something about the damage we do to the creatures around us. In 1973 Congress passed the Endangered Species Act, by a vote of 92 to 0 in the Senate and 390 to 12 in the House, and President Nixon signed it. It was not a liberal idea or a conservative idea then, just a decent one. The bald eagle is the creature most of us know best. In the early 1960s there were fewer than five hundred nesting pairs left in the lower forty-eight states, and today there are tens of thousands. Anyone who has watched one lift off a lake knows what we came close to losing.
In July, the Fish and Wildlife Service and the National Marine Fisheries Service removed the federal definition of the word “harm” from the Endangered Species Act. For about fifty years that word has protected more than individual animals. It has protected the places they live, the nesting ground, the river, the stand of forest where they feed and raise their young. Without it, destroying a species’ habitat no longer counts by itself as harming the species. The agencies say they are following the plain reading of the law, and the courts will have the final word on that.
In April, the Bureau of Land Management announced a lease sale of nearly seven hundred thousand acres of the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge, land that shelters caribou, wolves, and brown bears, and denning habitat for polar bears, which are already listed as threatened. Congress required those sales in a budget law last year. That same month, Congress voted to undo a mining ban on about 350 square miles of the Superior National Forest, the watershed that drains toward the Boundary Waters, and the President signed it. No mine has been approved yet, but the way is open for a copper and nickel mine upstream of one of the most loved wild places in America.
The king of Nineveh, a man with absolute power, wrote the animals into his decree and counted them among the ones he answered for. I believe a ruler answers for what he does with the land and the creatures on it, and that does not change depending on whether we happen to like the ruler.
Francis of Assisi is said to have preached to the birds and called the animals his brothers and sisters. People smile at that story, but in the thirteenth century he understood something the church had almost forgotten, that everything God has made is joined together in praise. His Canticle of the Creatures gives thanks for Brother Sun and Sister Moon, for Brother Wind and Sister Water, and for Sister Mother Earth, who sustains and governs us. To Francis, the earth was family.
I know many of us feel helpless about all of this. The news is heavy, the problems are enormous, and one person with a bird feeder doesn’t feel like much. I believe that grief is a faithful response, because someone who mourns what is being lost is someone whose heart is open, and an open heart is where caring begins. But grief that goes nowhere turns into numbness, and numbness is how we end up on Jonah’s hill with our arms folded. Caring takes something from us. It means paying attention, being willing to give up a little convenience, and speaking up when something we love is at risk, even when speaking up is uncomfortable.
So I invite you this week to pay attention to the creatures who share your yard or your street, the birds at the feeder, the squirrel on the fence, the neighbor’s dog. Say a quiet thank you for them. Then ask yourself whether anything you do makes life harder for them, and what we might do together for the creatures in this town. None of that will save the world, but Jonah’s whole trouble was that he could only see what was useful to him, and God keeps asking us to look wider.
God’s last question to Jonah is still hanging there, and God asks it of every church and every nation. Should I not care? About the enemy, about the child, about the cattle in the field? The book never tells us how Jonah answered, so I suppose the answer is left to us.
May we be a people who answer yes.
Amen.
Sign up to receive our weekly newsletter.